Dining & Drinks in Eleuthera

ABOUT ELEUTHERA

A Taste of Island Life

Dining on Eleuthera is an experience that blends island flavor with warm Bahamian hospitality.

Overview

From casual beachfront grills to cozy village eateries, you’ll find fresh seafood, tropical fruits, and Caribbean-inspired dishes that highlight the best of what the island has to offer. Eleuthera’s food scene isn’t about fast food or five-star formalities—it’s about authenticity, simplicity, and savoring every bite.

Local Restaurants & Must-Try Spots

  • Sammy’s Place (Rock Sound) – A local favorite for cracked conch, baked chicken, and peas ‘n’ rice.
  • Frigate’s Bar & Grill (Rock Sound) – Overlooking a marina, perfect for grilled seafood, burgers, and sunset cocktails.
  • Shantzii’s Sunset Shack (Tarpum Bay) – Colorful, laid-back, and ideal for grilled fish and rum drinks.
  • Delish at Sunset Inn (Governor’s Harbour) – Breezy restaurant with local dishes and beautiful views.
  • Tippy’s (Governor’s Harbour) – Known for wood-fired pizza, conch fritters, and live music by the beach.
  • The Front Porch (Hatchet Bay) – Reservation-only gem with hand-prepared seafood and homey atmosphere.

Beach Bars & Drink Spots

  • Sky Juice – A popular cocktail made with coconut water, condensed milk, and gin—served at many beach bars.
  • Kalik & Sands – Bahamian beers you’ll find at most local spots.
  • Goombay Smash – A fruity, rum-based punch that’s strong, sweet, and distinctly Bahamian.
  • Rum Punch – A staple on every island drink menu—varies by bar, always delicious.

Dining Tips & Local Flavor

  • Call ahead – Some restaurants operate on island time or close midweek; reservations are always a good idea.
  • Carry cash – Many smaller restaurants prefer or only accept cash (USD and BSD are interchangeable).
  • Ask for the catch of the day – Seafood is often caught fresh and varies by season and location.
  • Support local – Small family-run eateries often serve the most authentic and memorable meals.

Culinary Experiences

Want to take a piece of the island home with you? Try:

  • Cooking classes with local chefs
  • Visiting farmers markets for fresh fruits, hot sauces, and baked goods
  • Bringing home Bahamian spices, jams, or rum as gifts